Saw Garden State today, and while it was quite good, I have to present a less glowing review than Ben did.
I did not find this to be the defining movie of my generation. I will admit perhaps that this is a technicality since about half of the definitions put me in Generation X as compared to (and yes I looked this up): Millennial Generation, the Millennium Generation, the Net Generation, N-Gen, Generation NeXt or “NeXters,” Generation 2000, Generation Y2K, the Sunshine Generation, the Bittersweet Generation, the Hip-hop Generation, the Digital Generation, the Explorers, generation.com, e-Generation, little x-ers, Generation i (for Internet), the Little Boomers, the Boomlet, Generation Can-do, Generation “WHY?”, the Y-inistas, and the Bridgers. Generally this group is known as Generation Y simply because it follows generation X. This generation is generally considered 1982-present (with exceptions dating to 1979 and an end declared at 1994).
The exceptions going the other way would be those people whose parents were PRE baby-boom (aka alive during WWII) which includes my mother 1941, my father 1940(?) and my step-father 1931(?), and yes, I’m horrible with dates. So, working generationally instead of by dates, I am a baby boomer, I skipped 2 full generations, scary huh? (That said, I consider myself late Gen X culturally)
But, what most of this is here to say is that I identified with almost none of the movie, but it was a good enough movie that I wanted to explain why I am giving it what is likely a worse review than it deserves.
So, the real review, it starts out slow, has some excellent humor, good emotion, and is well filmed, but feels very chopped together without much flow from one segment to another. The movie uses color well, but sometimes abused that by fading between too many colors in the same scene, like an old black and white film would do to add a dash of color by tinting each shot.
The acting was excellent, I can’t really even nitpick anyone much. Natalie Portman showed a serious new range to her ability, but Ian Holm had too much of a Bilbo Baggins expression and stance for my taste. Unfortunately given the popularity of LotR I think he will really have to distance his mannerisms for me to appreciate him in another role.
Ben’s More Favorable Review